Unless you’ve been living under a rock (and perhaps even then) you’re probably aware that Facebook has a problem with fake news pages, fake accounts running subversive groups, and all other manner of bad intentioned accounts and content. Today Facebook announced new policies regarding the removal of content deemed to go against community standards from Facebook Pages and in Facebook Groups, as well as measures to crack down on preventing those who have had their content removed from simply reinventing themselves in a different page or group.
According to Facebook’s Statement on Making Pages More Transparent and Accountable, the two main changes are that they will be showing page admins when content from their page is removed for a policy violation, and how they deal with “recidivism”. Such policy violations will include hate speech, graphic violence, harassment and bullying, nudity or sexual activity*, and, and we quote, “support or praise of people and events that are not allowed to be on Facebook.”
We were particularly curious about that “praise of people” language, as that seems particularly thought-policey (well, ok, speech-policey) to us, so we went digging to see what we could find.
Here’s what Facebook says about that: “We do not allow content that praises any of the above organizations or individuals or any acts committed by them.”
The “above…individuals” that Facebook is referring to are:
- Leaders and prominent members of hate organizations
- Mass or serial murderers, whom Facebook defines as “any individual who has committed two or more murders over multiple incidents or locations using the following criteria:
- They were convicted of mass or serial murder.
- They were killed by law enforcement during commission of the mass or serial murder or during subsequent flight.
- They killed themselves at the scene or in the aftermath of the mass or serial murder.
- They were identified by law enforcement with images from the crime.
- Human trafficking group leaders
- Leaders and prominent members of criminal organizations, which Facebook defines as any association of 3 or more people involved in:
- Drug trafficking
- Arms trafficking
- Identity theft
- Money laundering
- Extortion or trafficking
- Sexual exploitation
*While Facebook touts their Community Standards, including against “Adult Nudity and Sexual Activity” and “Sexual Solicitation” on their Facebook Community Standards page, it was not that long ago that we received a blatant ad (and probably a scam) offering sex, reported it to Facebook, and was told that it did not violate their community standards. So, make of that what you will. You can see the ad and read all about it here: Facebook Allowing Profiles that are Overt Sex Ads – “Not Against Community Standards” says Facebook.
But we digress – anyways, the big deal about Facebook’s announcement today is what they are calling their “Recidivism Policy”.
|Get notified of new Internet Patrol articles for free!
|Or Read Internet Patrol Articles Right in Your Inbox!
as Soon as They are Published! Only $1 a Month!
Imagine being able to read full articles right in your email, or on your phone, without ever having to click through to the website unless you want to! Just $1 a month and you can cancel at any time!
Now, typically the term ‘recidivism’ is applied to criminal offenders who, after serving their time, relapse into criminal behaviour.
In Facebook’s use of the term, they mean people or organizations who, once having had a Facebook Page or Facebook Group removed for a policy violation, repurpose another page or group that they admin to start pushing material for the same violative purpose.
|No Paywall Here! The Internet Patrol is and always has been free. We don't hide our articles behind a paywall, or restrict the number of articles you can read in a month if you don't give us money. That said, it does cost us money to run the site, so if something you read here was helpful or useful, won't you consider donating something to help keep the Internet Patrol free?|
To combat this, Facebook will now preemptively remove other pages and groups “even if that specific Page or Group has not met the threshold to be unpublished on its own”, basing the decision on “a broad set of information, including whether the Page has the same people administering it, or has a similar name, to one we’re removing.”
In case you’d like to read it, here is Facebook’s full statement on the changes, which you can also read here.
We’d really like to know your thoughts on all of this, so please tell us what you think of this in a comment below.
Facebook’s Statement on Making Pages More Transparent and Accountable
We’re taking new steps in how we handle Page content that goes against our policies. First, starting tomorrow people who manage a Page will see a new tab that shows when we remove certain content that goes against our Community Standards and when we reduce the distribution of posts that have been rated false by a third-party fact-checker.
Second, we are updating our recidivism policy to better prevent those who have had Pages removed for violating our Community Standards from using duplicate Pages to continue the same activity. We’ll begin enforcing this policy in the weeks ahead.
The new Page Quality tab is designed to help people who manage Pages understand how well their Pages comply with our guidelines. The tab includes two sections:
1. Content we recently removed for violating a subset of our Community Standards and;
2. Content recently rated “False,” “Mixture” or “False Headline” by third-party fact-checkers.
We’ll be providing more information in the Page Quality tab over time. To start, we’re including content removed for policies like hate speech, graphic violence, harassment and bullying, and regulated goods, nudity or sexual activity, and support or praise of people and events that are not allowed to be on Facebook. While this tab provides greater insight into content that was removed or demoted, it is not a comprehensive accounting of all policy violations. For example, we won’t be showing content removals at this time for things like spam, clickbait, or IP violations.
We hope this will give people the information they need to police bad behavior from fellow Page managers, better understand our Community Standards, and, let us know if we’ve made an incorrect decision on content they posted.
Updates to Our Recidivism Policy
We’ve long prohibited people from creating new Pages, groups, events, or accounts that look similar to those we’ve previously removed for violating our Community Standards. However, we’ve seen people working to get around our enforcement by using existing Pages that they already manage for the same purpose as the Page we removed for violating our standards.
To address this gap, when we remove a Page or group for violating our policies, we may now also remove other Pages and Groups even if that specific Page or Group has not met the threshold to be unpublished on its own. To enforce this updated policy, we’ll look at a broad set of information, including whether the Page has the same people administering it, or has a similar name, to one we’re removing.
No Paywall Here!
The Internet Patrol is and always has been free. We don't hide our articles behind a paywall, or restrict the number of articles you can read in a month if you don't give us money. That said, it does cost us money to run the site, so if something you read here was helpful or useful, won't you consider donating something to help keep the Internet Patrol free? Thank you!
|Get notified of new Internet Patrol articles!