Many consumers rely heavily on the reviews of others before making purchase decisions. Whether Amazon, Yelp, Trip Advisor or Expedia, consumer reviews tend to heavily influence all types of purchase decisions, from toasters to vacations. We wrote this how-to guide a year ago, but with this week’s news of 19 companies being fined for fake reviews, we thought it was time to update it and remind you of it again.
In a recent sting operation set up by New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, the nineteen companies – some sites that post review, and some review writing organizations calling themeselves “reputation management” firms – were found to have participated in the writing, posting, and/or procuring of fake reviews.
In addition, it has been brought to light that there is an emerging trend of fake reviews being posted by the online merchants themselves, both giving themselves glowing reviews, and giving their competition scathing reviews. Book author RJ Ellory was outed by fellow authors after he was posting fake reviews under two different names, “Nicodemus Jones” and “Jelly Bean.” While calling his own work “chilling,” and a “modern masterpiece,” he blasted works from his rival authors. In response to legitimately poor reviews to his own work, he replied, as one of his alter egos, “Ignore all the dissenters and naysayers, this book is not trying to be anything other than a great story, brilliantly told. Whatever else it might do, it will touch your soul.” The jig was up when he unwittingly signed a few of the false reviews with his real name.
The problem with reviews is that most people who post fake reviews are very good at what they do. They make a point to make their reviews look and sound like other reviews, despite the ratings typically being on one end of the spectrum, or the other. The problem with only relying on the extreme ratings to tip you off as to whether the review is a fake is that very positive, or very negative, experiences can also prompt someone to post a review.
When analysts compared reviews between TripAdvisor and Expedia, they found a big difference between the two sites. While Expedia typically requires that reviewers have bought hotel stays through Expedia in order to review, anyone could post a review on TripAdvisor. Interestingly what they found is that on Expedia, where reviewers had to be actual customers, the ratings tended to be more in the middle. On TripAdvisor, where anyone could post, the ratings trended to either very good, or very bad, suggesting a higher prevalence of fake reviews.
|Pssst! Get notified of new TIP articles here:|
Experts offer a few suggestions to ensure that savvy consumers can navigate reviews and use them best to their advantage:
- Compare reviews across different websites, rather than just taking the word of reviewers on one site.
- Put more stock in reviews by those who are verified by the site, rather than anonymous reviews. Also, check out the other reviews by a questionable reviewer to see if they’ve reviewed other products or services, and what their ratings tend to be.
- Look more at the details within the review, rather than the actual rating given. A recent search for hiking shoes on Amazon.com turned up a particular shoe, known for being a high performer on other sites, with only a mediocre rating on Amazon. A closer look revealed that the reviews with low ratings were not about the shoe itself, but rather about the experience the reviewers had with the shipping of the shoes.
- Trends are hard to fake. While a few high ratings, or low ratings, could easily be fake, trends one way or another are likely more legitimate.
Above all, make sure that whatever you are buying, hotel rooms or hiking shoes, the merchant offers a reasonable return or refund policy. Even a collection of the most favorable, and authentic, reviews, cannot account for personal preference.
(Hey! Please let us know if you liked this article by leaving us a comment!)
You might also like some of our other articles: