If You Use Challenge/Response It May Be Your Email Delivery Which is Challenged   - 5,347 Views, 6 Comments

Summary: If you are one of the thousands of users who uses a challenge/response system to stem the flow of email into your inbox, you may be missing out on more than just spam. One of the inherent flaws in challenge/response systems is that they ...

Previous Article « Have You Been Spammed by Microsoft?
Read Next Article » Play Along with Aunty! Do Cookies Count As Spyware?

  Follow Anne on Twitter     Friend Anne on Facebook

If you are one of the thousands of users who uses a challenge/response system to stem the flow of email into your inbox, you may be missing out on more than just spam.

One of the inherent flaws in challenge/response systems is that they don’t work if the sender never receives the challenge.

And that’s just what has been happening in the case of email sent by users at both Earthlink and AOL, where the challenges have been ending up in the spam folder instead of going to the sender for a response.

Email which cannot be delivered until the response to the challenge is received is stored in a “quarantine folder”, to which the intended recipient has access, but of course that requires the user to manually review the email in the quarantine folder, at which point it’s not really that different than checking a spam folder. In which case what’s the point of having the challenge/response system in the first place?

The challenge/response system to be most recently plagued by this problem is Mailblocks, whose challenges were going into the spam folder at both AOL and Earthlink as recently as last week. What makes this even more frustrating is that Mailbocks is owned by AOL, having been acquired by them last August.

So, if you are using a challenge/response system, be sure to check your quarantine folder to see if you have some mail hanging out in there waiting for a challenge response which will never come. And if you are an AOL or Earthlink sender, and you know that some of your correspondents use a challenge/response system, you may want to double-check that they have received your email if you don’t receive an anticipated reply from them.

You can read more about this here

If You Use Challenge/Response It May Be Your Email Delivery Which is Challenged

 Follow Anne on Twitter

 Twitter Explained in Plain English

 Friend Anne on Facebook

Previous Article « Have You Been Spammed by Microsoft?
Read Next Article » Play Along with Aunty! Do Cookies Count As Spyware?

Read more:

»  Post Office Begs to Cut Saturday Delivery as Email Further Impacts USPS Income

»  Domain Keys “Adopted” by Phishers

»  When Spammers Sue the Spammed

»  Have You Been Spammed by Microsoft?

For additional similar stories check out our archives on Everything Else

NOTE: We never, ever, ever will recommend any product or service on this site that we have not regularly used ourselves and do not wholeheartedly believe in. That said, in some cases after being very pleased with a product or service, we may enter into a relationship with the provider of that product or service such that if someone purchases that product or service based on our recommendation, we may get a small payment. Such payments go towards the upkeep of the Internet Patrol.

 

6 Comments »

  1. If You Use Challenge/Response It May Be Your Email Delivery Which is Challenged
    If you are one of the thousands of users who uses a challenge/response system to stem the flow of email into your inbox, you may be missing out on more than just spam. One of the inherent flaws in challenge/response…

    Trackback by Lockergnome's Windows Fanatics — 11/8/2004 @ 9:20 am

  2. If You Use Challenge/Response It May Be Your Email Delivery Which is Challenged
    If you are one of the thousands of users who uses a challenge/response system to stem the flow of email into your inbox, you may be missing out on more than just spam. One of the inherent flaws in challenge/response…

    Trackback by Lockergnome's Windows Fanatics — 11/8/2004 @ 9:28 am

  3. Neat. Symmetric challenge-response systems eating each others challenges.

    “I can’t read your email until you respond to this challenge”

    “Oh yeah, well I can’t respond to your challenge until *you* respond to *this* challenge”

    “Uh, well I’ll respond to your challenge when you respond to my challenge to your challenge to my challenge”

    etc.

    Comment by Craig Hughes — 11/8/2004 @ 10:07 am

  4. “I can’t read your email until you respond to this challenge�

    “Oh yeah, well I can’t respond to your challenge until *you* respond to *this* challenge�

    “Uh, well I’ll respond to your challenge when you respond to my challenge to your challenge to my challenge�

    “Oh yeah? Well EAT MY CHALLENGE!

    Hey..wait..I didn’t mean it…”

    Comment by Aunty Spam — 11/8/2004 @ 10:12 am

  5. how can i sign up for your email?

    Comment by voxpop@ev1.net — 11/9/2004 @ 6:25 am

  6. Voxpop wrote:

    “how can i sign up for your email?”

    You can either press the button in the upper right hand corner of this page which says”Subscribe to Aunty’s Free Newsletter!”,
    or you can visit the sign-up site directly at http://lists.isipp.com/mailman/listinfo/net-patrol.

    Kissy kissy,

    Aunty

    Comment by Aunty — 11/9/2004 @ 9:45 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Warning! All comments which contain URLs and are clearly just spam to generate a link back to the URL will be deleted on sight. Don't bother wasting your time!

If you are going to include a URL in your comment,
please keep it under 25 characters in length,
or use TinyURL to shorten it before including it in your comment.

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic, your email address is never displayed.
HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)


If you have not posted a comment here before, we apologize for having to ask you to enter the letters and numbers you see in the image above to validate your comment, but we are being attacked by thousands of comment form spams every day! You only need to do this once; once you have successfuly posted a comment here you will not be asked to do this again. Thank you for your understanding!

 
 This article first appeared on 11/8/2004
The Internet Patrol
Patrolling the Internet for You!